15 Best Subscription Boxes for Men, Tested and Reviewed
Updated: Jun. 18, 2024
From coffee beans and pasture-raised meat to cologne and beer deliveries, these subscription boxes for men are sure to satisfy every interest.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.Learn more.
Not all men are alike, so why should subscription boxes for men be identical? Some men are tech aficionados while others spend all of their time in the great outdoors. Some men are dedicated plant dads (hello, plant subscription boxes) while others can’t wait to test out their grilling skills or showcase their knowledge as amateur mixologists. That’s why subscription boxes are so fun—and make the best gifts for men. Not only are they convenient (just choose the frequency and the products you’d like delivered), they’re also extremely personalized. The best subscription services offer style or preference quizzes, so your vegan husband won’t find wagyu steak in his box, and your yoga-loving best friend can count on Zen-like items rather than noisy ones.
There are subscription boxes for every interest and hobby out there. There are even clothing rental services that make great gifts for boyfriends, gifts for husbands or gifts for dads. If you’d like to surprise someone with an unexpected gift or just want to treat yourself to convenient cologne, clothing or wine deliveries, consider the best subscription boxes for men, as tested by our team.
Best overall subscription box for men
Bespoke Post
Pros:
- Unique options, including camping gear and barware
- Customizable and premium box options
- À la carte shopping options
- Supports small brands
- Prices start at $49
Cons:
- Boxes may sell out
We all know someone who wants the finer (or quirkier) things in life. One of the more fun subscription boxes for men is Bespoke Post, which offers a variety of products every month that you might not find elsewhere. Every month, you’ll receive an email with details about what’s inside your shipment, such as a weekender bag, a waffle-knit T-shirt, joggers, cozy slippers, a miniature indoor fireplace and a dopp kit. It can include anything from shaving sets and shoe-shine kits to barware and other home goods.
“My $49 Explore box was stocked with hiking must-haves, which led me to start planning my next outdoor trek,” says our tester, Andrea Carrillo. “The boxes regularly rotate, so you’ll always have access to spectacular picks.” And if you’re not feeling the items in his next shipment, you can customize, switch or even skip the month’s box.
You can also go beyond the monthly subscription and purchase a variety of products from Bespoke Post’s e-commerce store, including kitchen essentials (knives, cutting boards, collections of fine sauces and sweet and savory spreads), outdoor gear, home decor and more.
Best value subscription box for men
Cratejoy
Pros:
- Prices start at $10 and most are under $50
- Hundreds of boxes to choose from
- Flexible subscription plans
- Supports small businesses
Cons:
- Not every box has reviews to go off of
If you’ve never heard of Cratejoy, you’re in for a treat. Consider it the subscription box mecca, where you’ll find a box for just about every interest, hobby and palate. There are hundreds of boxes to choose from, including some unique picks that he won’t be able to stop talking about, like the paranormal-themed Cryptid Crate and scientific Box of Matter. But best of all, boxes start at around just $10. Some vendors even offer coupons allowing you to save even more, and most vendors give you the option of one-, three-, six- or 12-month subscription plans.
“The marketplace has all kinds of hidden gems, which I love. It’s super giftable, whether you want to treat yourself to a self-care Therabox or gift a monthly vintage teacup to a friend,” writes Carrillo, noting some options for women in her beauty subscription box review.
She also adds that you won’t find a ton of high-end products or brand names in these boxes, and not every box has a ton of reviews. However, she adds that her box arrived quickly and neatly packaged.
Best subscription box for the sharp dresser
Stitch Fix
Pros:
- Personal shopper selects clothing
- No subscription required
- Personalized pricing
- Includes well-known brands and Stitch Fix-specific ones
- Prices start at $20
Cons:
- $20 styling fee (but goes toward purchase)
- You must pack and return items you don't want
Most people know about Stitch Fix for women, but did you know there’s a men’s subscription box, too? Anyone ready to discover new styles simply takes a style quiz. After that, stylists will choose pieces that best reflect your style, and each month, you’ll receive a box of clothing. The $20 stylist’s fee will be applied to anything you end up buying.
While you won’t find high-end fashion in these boxes, you will find a variety of products, including outerwear, footwear, office and casual wear and men’s pajamas, as well as tried-and-true brands, such as Bonobos, Faherty, Barbour and Tommy Bahama.
“I’ve been a loyal Stitch Fix subscriber for more than five years,” says deputy shopping editor, Reina Galhea. “It’s helped me find some of my favorite closet items—both staples and special occasion outfits. I’m also impressed with the men’s selection, which is on par with what I’ve found at quality department stores. Now my husband is on the Stitch Fix train, too!”
Best subscription box for the gadget hound
Breo Box
Pros:
- Fun gadgets, including drones and smart key organizers
- Seasonal and annual subscription plans
- May come with high-end items
- Mystery boxes available for $89
Cons:
- Limited boxes each season
- Prices start at $175
For the tech enthusiast who loves giving and receiving the best tech gifts, this monthly subscription box includes anywhere from four to eight gadgets revolving around tech, home goods and more. While Breo Box isn’t strictly for men, it does make a great birthday or anniversary gift, and includes everything from drones and gaming devices to tech wearables and wireless essentials—maybe even a retro tech gadget worth a lot of money. Different plans are also available, so you can buy a box for one month only or a box each season.
And while Breo Box doesn’t come cheap, you can rest assured that it’s a great value. “My box arrived with an assortment that included a nut milk maker valued at $180, which on its own is already worth more than the cost of the box. I also received a universal smart charger, jar lid remover and a few other fun goodies that I could see myself using every day,” writes shopping editor, Emily Way. “It’s a thoughtful gift for anyone who’s always hunting down the latest gizmos.”
Best subscription box for the coffee lover
Bean Box
Pros:
- Whole-bean and freshly ground coffee
- Easy to modify your preferences
- Customize volume and frequency of deliveries
- Prices start at $22
Cons:
- Limited offerings
You’ve already gotten your favorite java junkie the best gifts for coffee lovers, including all the mugs and machines on the market. So how about a coffee subscription box? Bean Box subscriptions allow you to choose between ground coffee or actual coffee beans, choose the ideal tasting experience (light and bright? curator’s choice?) and choose the amount and frequency of your coffee delivery. Each bag of coffee brews 24 to 36 cups and can be delivered every two or four weeks.
Our tester, Megan Mowery, loves that the month’s beans arrive conveniently at your door, so no more emergency coffee runs when you’ve unexpectedly hit empty on your current bag. Plus, Bean Box takes personal preferences into account when determining the specific coffees to fill your box, so it’s easy to receive the perfect brew for your tastes month after month. They even allow you to modify your subscription as your tastes change over time.
Best subscription box for the label lover
Scentbird
Pros:
- Extensive collection of scents
- Free atomizer case with your first shipment
- Travel- and TSA-friendly sizes
- Flexible subscription plans
- Prices start at $17
Cons:
- Can be difficult to cancel
For the guy who loves to smell great, Scentbird‘s cologne subscriptions are a no-brainer. This monthly subscription box for men takes all the guesswork out of the cologne-buying experience. Choose from brand-name and lesser-known labels, and every month you’ll receive a 0.27-ounce vial of your chosen cologne, including luxury brands such as Tocca, Marc Jacobs, Versace, Tom Ford and more. The bottle holds roughly 120 sprays, which is about a month’s worth of cologne.
“I love travel perfume because I can experiment with new scents and pop one in my purse or travel backpack. Most travel-size bottles at Sephora or Ulta are about $30, and Scentbird offers the same for about half the cost.” Carrillo, whose husband is also a fan of Scentbird, refers to the brand’s extensive selection of scents as dizzying. However, choosing a scent is easier than you might think. All you have to do is create a scent profile, which will link you to over 700 different brands and scents. “I chose Commodity’s Paper+ Bold (a delicious, musky book smell) based on Scentbird’s recommendations and helpful and expansive perfume reviews,” she explains. “It didn’t disappoint.”
Best subscription box for the hops lover
City Brew Tours
Pros:
- Includes craft brews from around the U.S.
- Monthly livestream with the brewers
- Public and private brewery tours in select cities
- Prices start at $79.99
- Boxes ship for free
Cons:
- No month-to-month subscription plan
Whether he’s a craft beer snob or just wants to experience new beer, City Brew Tour’s subscription service grants customers access to the best breweries across the country. Each month, City Brew Tours features a different city and sends you eight beers from three to four of the best local craft breweries—but that’s not all. City Brew Tours has its own monthly podcast so you can learn all about the brews.
“Your friend will love getting philosophical about their new favorite IPA when they tune in for the monthly subscriber Zoom call tasting featuring guest speakers, brewing experts and fellow beer enthusiasts,” says Way. And if you want to delve even deeper into the world of craft beer, pack your bags and book one of City Brew Tours’ public or private brewery tours, which are offered in select cities.
Best subscription box for the practical shopper
Menlo Club
Pros:
- Includes several brands under their main label
- Each box builds on the one that came before
- Pause or cancel any time
- Prices start at $60
- Free shipping
Cons:
- No returns allowed
As far as wardrobe refreshers go, Menlo Club is a quality option for adding key items to your closet on a monthly basis (hello, capsule wardrobe!). Simply take a style quiz to determine your personal taste, sizing and overall profile. Then, for $60 a month, you’ll receive two or three pieces of curated apparel—such as shoes, jackets, shirts, pants, jeans and more—meant to complement your existing wardrobe and any shipments Menlo Club has already sent you.
“My husband really loved the clothes and shoes he got,” says our tester, Stephanie Hope. “They’re ones he might not have thought to buy on his own but they’re the perfect complement to his closet.” And to help you build your wardrobe even more, you’ll also receive a 25% off discount to use toward other purchases.
Best subscription box for the meat lover
Porter Road
Pros:
- Fresh cuts of pasture-raised meat
- No hormones or antibiotics
- Flexible delivery options
- Customizable options
- Prices start at $45
Cons:
- Shipping isn't free
Calling all carnivores! Last-minute grocery store runs are a thing of the past, thanks to Porter Road’s meat delivery subscriptions. Snackers will enjoy their beef stick subscription while home chefs and pitmasters will get their grill on with one of the brand’s carefully curated boxes. Our tester, Allison Robicelli, recommends the popular butcher’s choice box which includes eight to 10 pounds of various cuts of your choice like pork chops, ground beef, sirloin filets, pork tenderloin, chicken breast, chorizo links—the list goes on.
All meat is pasture-raised on sustainable family farms and ranches without any hormones or antibiotics so no matter what you order, you can rest assured it’s top quality. Choose to have your box delivered every two, four or eight weeks and you can cancel anytime. “All in all, Porter Road is an excellent option for regular ordering. They’ve got a little bit of everything—and it’s all good,” writes Robicelli.
Best subscription box for the sweet tooth
Feed Your Soul
Pros:
- Individually wrapped cookies or brownies
- No artificial colors or preservatives
- Your purchase gives back
- Free shipping
- One month equals less than $45
Cons:
- No month-to-month subscription plans
Guys who enjoy a sweet treat at the end of a long day will love receiving this box of sweet treats from Feed Your Soul each month. Each shipment includes either a dozen delicious cookies in flavors, like Snickerdoodle, Lemonberry and Cocoa Loco. “In my tests of the Feed Your Soul cookie subscription, the cookies were moist, tender and oh-so-yummy,” writes Way.
If cookies aren’t your jam, you can opt for a dozen delectable brownies in flavors, such as One Toff Blondie, Coconut Magic and Almond French Toast. And yes, this cookie subscription box really is good for your soul. Each purchase gives back meals (and cookies!) to those in need. Just keep in mind that there isn’t a month-to-month option, and instead it costs $134.95 for three months.
Best subscription box for the mixologist
Shaker & Spoon
Pros:
- Each box makes 12 drinks
- Includes recipe cards and how-to videos
- Change or cancel at any time
- No subscription required
- Prices start at $59
Cons:
- Alcohol isn't included
Up your cocktail game with this Shaker & Spoon cocktail kit. Each month, you’ll receive a box built around one spirit with ingredients to make three unique and delicious recipes (12 drinks total). “I never would have thought to put some of these ingredients together, so it was nice to have these options to mix up my rum cocktails, especially as a Jamaican,” says our tester, Cher Checchio.
And if the extent of your bartending experience is pouring a glass of wine or simply cracking open a cold one, don’t worry. Each box comes with a recipe card, access to how-to videos and recommendations from the pros on which bottle of alcohol pairs best with your cocktails. Note: Alcohol isn’t included in the boxes, but the cocktail syrups, bitters, garnishes, aromatics and other ingredients for craft cocktails are.
Best subscription box for the dog dad
BarkBox
Pros:
- Customizable boxes for your pup
- Heavy-chewer options
- Optional add-ons available
- Fun monthly themes
- Prices start at $20
Cons:
- Only six- or 12-month subscription plans offered
Don’t forget Fido! His best four-legged friend will yelp for joy upon receiving BarkBox’s monthly subscription. Each box includes two plush toys, two bags of treats and a fun surprise. Our content director of affiliate, Nicole Doster says that BarkBox is her favorite thing to gift other pet owners. “Bark Box just has so many cute toys that are surprisingly durable and have become favorites for our dog. I especially love their food-themed toys,” she says. “We got a box that featured all classic ice cream treats…it’s so fun to watch Huey run around with a Choco Taco in his mouth!”
Boxes are customizable and can be tailored based on the dog’s size, food sensitivities, chew style, breed and more. You can even add extra toys or treats for those who have been very good pups.
Best subscription box for the horologist
Watch Gang
Pros:
- Watches are worth $150 to $1,500
- Weekly Rolex, Tag Huer and Seiko giveaways
- Includes premium and craft watch brands
- Three membership tiers to choose from
- Prices start at $59.99
Cons:
- You can't choose which watches you receive
- No returns or refunds
Love your Apple Watch but want something a bit fancier? Watch Gang is one of the fun subscription boxes for men who want to build a watch collection. Simply sign up for the service and, every month, a new watch will arrive in your mailbox. First, tell them about you (whether you’re an in-office executive, an off-road adventurer or all of the above). Then choose from three subscription plans: original tier (starts at $59.99 per box), black tier (starts at $119.99 per box), platinum tier (starts at $319.99 per box).
Hope says her husband appreciated the variety of subscription options, which allow you to grow your collection at your own pace and price. Once you decide which tier fits your needs and budget, you won’t have to wait long for your new timepiece. Your brand-new watch will be shipped within three business days.
Best subscription box for the capsaicin connoisseur
Heatonist
Pros:
- Includes flavor profiles for each sauce
- Flexible subscription plans
- Skip, pause or cancel at any time
- Yearly subscription perks
- Prices start at $30
Cons:
- Can't be customized
Satisfy your need for heat with a hot sauce subscription from Heatonist. Every month, you’ll receive three bottles of hot sauce Hot Ones and/or sauces from Hot Ones’ favorite makers. You can’t choose your flavors, but you can rest assured that you’ll receive a range of flavors and heat levels.
“My box arrived with three very different sauces of different heat levels,” says Way. “I also appreciated the inclusion of a very in-depth analysis of each sauce’s spice levels, pairing notes and a little about the brands.” You’ll also appreciate the fun, limited-edition Hot Ones stickers included in each box.
Best subscription box for the trendsetter
GQ Box
Pros:
- Unique, useful products, including apparel and grooming supplies
- Exclusive access to the GQ Store
- Skip or cancel at any time
- Boxes won't repeat
- Prices start at $59
- Free shipping
Cons:
- Can't be customized
There are plenty of beauty subscription boxes full of makeup, hair and skincare products for women, but the GQ Box was designed with men in mind. Each quarter, you’ll receive a box full of goodies including accessories, apparel, skincare and grooming products, as well as other fun surprises that are valued at more than $200. You’ll also get special subscriber access to the GQ Exclusive Store, where you can save up to 75% off retail prices.
Hope points out that the GQ Best Stuff Box is great value for the price and is almost sure to have something for everyone. “You get a good mix of practical accessories like a watch, bag or Bluetooth speaker, plus some skincare/grooming products, clothing and other items,” she explains. “It’s a fun way to pick up some new favorites every season without having to search far and wide!”
What to look for when buying subscription boxes for men
When shopping for the best subscription boxes for men, start by considering their hobbies and interests, as well as your budget. Below are some additional considerations:
- Frequency: Choose how often you’d like the subscription box delivered. Some services offer weekly deliveries while others offer monthly or seasonal options.
- Customization options: If you’re shopping for a guy who’s on the picker side, look for a subscription service that allows you to customize your box. Some brands allow you to preview boxes and select items based on factors such as dietary restrictions or personal preferences. If you don’t like what’s being offered, you can swap items or skip that month altogether. Other subscription services take a “you get what you get and you don’t get upset” approach, which can be fun for some but seem wasteful to others.
- Managing the subscription: The best subscription boxes for men should make it easy for you to skip, pause or cancel your subscription at any time should it no longer suit your needs or budget.
Why you should trust us
Our team of editors love testing the latest and greatest products on the market. To choose the best subscription boxes for men, our testers—Andrea Carillo, Reina Galhea, Stephanie Hope, Emily Way, Cher Checcio, Nicole Doster and Megan Mowery, who have years of experience in the commerce world—tried dozens of subscription boxes and were able to detail which boxes offered the best value and selection. Many of our testers also presented boxes to their significant others and were able to assess how men actually felt about the quality and selection of goods in each box.
How we found the best subscription boxes for men
After thoroughly researching top brands and scouring customer reviews, our team of editors ordered dozens of the best subscription boxes on the market, taking into consideration a range of interests, styles and budgets. We paid attention to the selection and quality of goods in each box, as well as the value and flexibility of each subscription plan. We also made note of which subscription plans saddled us with additional fees or shipping costs, and those that don’t allow for customization or returns. After all, these subscription boxes should be fun, and surprise costs are anything but. Keeping all of these factors in mind, we narrowed down our selection to 15 subscription boxes worthy of the men in our lives.
FAQ
How does a subscription box for men work?
Depending on the frequency you choose, you pay a weekly, monthly or yearly fee and he’ll get a box of fun goods delivered to his door in exchange.
Can I give a subscription box for men as a gift?
Yes! Many of the subscription boxes on our list have a gift option. Just be sure to have their physical and email addresses on hand.
Additional reporting by Rachel Weingarten.
Originally Published: February 28, 2023
